School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2-Food, family, and community are the heart of debut author/illustrator Himes's retelling of the classic Hans Christian Andersen story. Ma Sally, "the best cook in Charleston County, South Carolina," is concerned when her son John wants to get married, because the local gals might not feed him right, so she plans a cooking contest to see if anyone is worthy. Kind and thoughtful John is considered a catch, and several women answer the call. After they fail to impress Ma Sally in the kitchen, a newcomer to town arrives at Ma Sally's, saying she heard about some kind of contest. Introducing herself, Princess sets to work making the best peas Ma Sally has ever tasted. Princess then suggests that John might take her dancing-after he washes the dishes, of course. The narrative's rhythm and pacing hearken back to its fairy-tale roots, and the rich text ("tables groaned under crocks") will have readers' mouths watering. Himes immerses children in the Formica world of the 1950s setting, and the pastel-colored backgrounds make the characters practically pop off the page. Her textured acrylic, watercolor, and mixed-media illustrations add dimension, bringing readers into a vibrant African American community that they'll want to return to again and again. Princess's winning pea recipe is appended. VERDICT This retelling of a classic tale is a fresh interpretation and a fun read-aloud. A first purchase for most collections.-Danielle Jones, Multnomah County Library, OR © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
In her first children's book, Himes transplants Andersen's "The Princess and the Pea" to an African-American community in mid-20th-century South Carolina, where a young man named John thinks it's about time that he got married. His mother, Ma Sally, an acclaimed local cook, has mixed feelings: "She couldn't bear the thought of her only child sitting down to an ill-cooked meal." Thus it's decided that John's prospective bride will have to whip up a batch of black-eyed peas that pass muster with Ma Sally. Demonstrating one's smarts and skill in the kitchen is a definite step up from simply being sensitive to foreign objects hidden under a mattress or 20, and Himes's heroine, Princess, is no pushover. "I like John well enough, but I've got my own plans," she says, setting aside any notions of a shotgun marriage. Instead, she suggests a date at the juke point and makes sure that John is doing his share: "Why don't you show me how you scrub them pots and pans?" Rendered in a flattened, folk art style, Himes's paintings lovingly evoke the period setting, highlighting the community's warmth, traditions, and fashion. Ages 5-8. (Apr.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.