School Library Journal Review
Gr 4-7-Where do adolescent bullies go to turn their lives around? And what would it be like if they all went to school together? Those questions form the basis of Weinberger's debut, which follows wrongfully accused sixth grader Ian Hart as he and his friends Ash, Mark, and Devon attend a summer reform school for bullies called JANUS. Ian's inner monologue is frequently troubled by an entity he refers to as The Freak, a stand-in for his adolescent social awkwardness and, more important, his budding individuality. Weinberger gives Ian a self-deprecating voice that will appeal to "Wimpy Kid" fans who are interested in exploring the ethical questions facing middle schoolers. Vivid supporting characters, including a pair of feuding dancers and a renegade computer hacker, provide color and comic relief. But Ian's closer friends, especially Devon, the book's main antagonist and the party responsible for the group's summerlong detention, would have benefited from further development. Weinberger tries to work too many of Ian's fantasies into the story (in addition to The Freak, there's an imaginary ghost of Thomas Edison and a sort-of time-traveling toilet), which can be confusing. VERDICT An entertaining and quirky read, suitable for fans of Tom Angleberger, Jeff Kinney, and James Roy.-Abigail Garnett, Brooklyn Public Library © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
Twelve-year-old Ian has a set of rules designed to avoid being bullied, including "be quiet and fit in." Ian's friend Devon looks out for him, too, though Devon can be a bully himself. When Ian is an unwitting accessory to an allergic boy's exposure to peanut butter, Ian, Devon, and two other friends are sent to a summer school for bullies. There, Ian vents his frustrations to the spirit of Thomas Edison ("You were my age once.... How did you transform from a twelve-year-old dropout to a self-taught inventor guy?"), nurses an inner voice he thinks of as "the Freak" that longs to speak up, and confides in friends Ash and Alva. Weinberger's debut is filled with stunts and pranks that many readers will recognize, and when Devon goes too far, Ian is finally compelled to confront him. Ian's fears of being bullied and guilt at not standing up for himself and others are strongly felt, although his wry observations and joking relationship with Ash add layers of levity to this coming-of-age journey. Ages 8-12. (Mar.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.