School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up--McBride presents another affecting author/narrator performance of her sophomore novel in verse, repeating the dual-credited success of her 2021 National Book Award Finalist debut, Me (Moth). Her opening "A Note Before Entering the Forest," which warns of "clinical depression, self-harm & suicide," sets a somber tone throughout. Atmospheric music announces each new chapter in the recovery journey of two teens, Whimsy and Faerry, who meet while hospitalized. The members of their group therapy circle to which Whimsy "assign[s] each person a Fairy Tale name" will play vital roles in the pair's survival. An author's note insistently reminds, "Stories keep the world intact." Whimsy & Faerry's Playlist follows, ending with acknowledgments that underscore the lifesaving power of poetry. VERDICT McBride's self-described "book about depression & pain & hope" is a healing balm for suffering souls.
Publisher's Weekly Review
McBride, the author of Me (Moth), employs lilting poetic wordplay to weave familiar fairy tales with original, resonant fables in this haunting verse novel. When human poet Whimsy is hospitalized with clinical depression, she meets and immediately connects with a Fae boy named Faerry. After getting discharged, she learns that Faerry has just moved into a house on Whimsy's street and soon realizes their intense familiarity hints at a shared past that neither of them seems to remember. Working together to unearth buried memories, the teens battle a fantastical physical embodiment of sorrow and struggle to face their inexplicable fear of the forest at the end of their street. Sparse yet expressive verse ("We are floating in a circle/ made from hope & crystal wings") grounds mystical happenings, such as Whimsy and Faerry's meetings with characters from classic fairy tales and folklore, including Anansi, Baba Yaga, and Snow White. Drawing from personal experience, as detailed in a beginning note, McBride delivers a dark, whimsical adventure that viscerally depicts experiences of clinical depression, generational trauma, racism, self-harm, suicidal ideation, and survivor's guilt. A glossary of the fairy tales referenced concludes. Whimsy and Faerry are Black. Ages 14--17. Agent: Rena Rossner, Deborah Harris Agency. (Jan.)