School Library Journal Review
Gr 1-3-When Matthew loses one of his ewes, her lamb leads the young shepherd to a small stable, where its mother is keeping watch over Mary, Joseph, and baby Jesus. Matthew is so overcome with love and reverence for the baby that he gives the family both the ewe and her lamb. Although both the text and the golden-hued scratchboard illustrations create a cozy and loving atmosphere, young readers may find the stillness and serenity somewhat dull. Matthew appears to be about 10 years old in some illustrations and a teenager in others, and many of the figures are rather stiff in both expression and pose. Not a first choice.-E. M. (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
Young shepherd Matthew worries when one of his sheep goes astray, leaving her baby behind. But the hungry lamb, with Matthew on its trail, locates its mother in a warm and peaceful place the stable where Jesus lays. Matthew basks in the comfort he feels in Jesus' presence and offers the sheep and lamb as gifts to the holy family. Colon's (My Mama Had a Dancing Heart) signature luminous artwork conveys a reverence and intimacy that will quickly capture the imagination of youngsters. Ages 4-9. (Oct.) FYI: A Spanish-language edition, El regalo del pastor, trans. by Osvaldo Blanco ($15.95 ISBN 0-06-029785-9), is also available. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved