School Library Journal Review
Gr 1--2--It is late autumn when the Kelly family receives a package containing a jigsaw puzzle of an African swimming hole at sunrise from an anonymous sender. The card reads, "Good luck to you all." The Kellys (Mom, Dad, Kitty, Katie, and Lucy the dog) happily take on the challenge. Unbeknownst to them, the illustrations show that almost immediately a puzzle piece is dropped and ends up in the trash. Life is busy, but as time permits, they work on the puzzle. It is nearly the following autumn before it is almost done and they discover, "ONE PIECE IS MISSING!" Clever Mom deducts that the piece must have been thrown away. With hope in their hearts, they head to the dump to find the puzzle piece of Hippo's swim trunks. While searching through a huge pile of paper trash, they find many things, but not the puzzle piece. Luckily, it finds them. As they head home in defeat, it sticks to the bottom of Dad's shoe. It falls off on the kitchen floor, where Katie finds it, and together the Kellys complete their beautiful puzzle. Graham's delightful ink and watercolor illustrations are an integral part of the story. They not only take the text to the next level with fun details and expressions, but in places deliberately and effectively replace it altogether. VERDICT A love letter to jigsaw puzzlers young and old, and a lighthearted reflection on things lost and found. The mystery of who sent the package remains unsolved. Purchase where Graham's books are popular.--Catherine Callegari
Publisher's Weekly Review
When the Kelly family receives a jigsaw puzzle in the mail, the package has no return address--just an unsigned card that reads "Good luck to you all." What follows--for jigsaw puzzle fans, anyway--is almost too painful to relate. In softly tinted watercolor and ink art, Graham (Ellie's Dragon) conjures "a beautiful jigsaw--an African sunrise," depicting a bunch of animals captured in mid-air above a swimming hole. As the white-presenting family dives in, images reveal almost immediately to readers that a piece has gone missing, planting the seed for the comedy gold that ensues. Months later, Dad sees the hole in the all-but-finished puzzle ("ONE PIECE IS MISSING!"), and the highly invested family heads to the paper recycling center to search for the missing piece, in the process sorting through fragments of memory and time: letters of love and sorrow, train tickets, and newspapers. The ending of this beguiling little gem resolves one mystery but leaves another open-ended, cleverly meditating on the way that slow-burn quandaries and jigsaw puzzle time--both of which move in seasons, not seconds--can be conducive to contentment. Ages 3--7. (July)