School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--7--Clementine has always tried to be as bad as possible, following the example of her father, the Dark Lord Elithor, who strives to terrify the local villagers with dastardly deeds. Everything changes when Lord Elithor starts to lose his power at the hands of a mysterious witch. Clementine's quest to save her father brings her a host of new experiences and leads her to question her commitment to being truly evil. Horwitz has created a perfect blend of wit and heart in this fresh fantasy adventure. Even secondary characters are given intriguing personalities and well-developed back stories, and the plot is paced just quickly enough to keep young people guessing. Fans of Shrek-style fractured fairy tales will especially enjoy having their expectations upended. VERDICT Highly recommended, this title will keep a wide variety of readers entertained with its compelling characters and witty twists on the fairy tale universe.--Gesse Stark-Smith, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OR
Publisher's Weekly Review
"Clementine Morcerous awoke one morning to discover that her father had no nose." With her opening sentence, Horwitz (the Carmer and Grit series) primes readers to expect the unexpected--and delivers. After Clementine notices that something is "chipping away" at her parent, the fearsome Dark Lord, he corrects her: "Not. Chipping....Whittling." Such droll wordplay punctuates the labyrinthine narrative, which reveals that the Dark Lord has been cursed by his archnemesis, the Whittle Witch, who carves a wooden-doll replica of her victims and reduces them down to nothing. Horwitz's ingenuity for bizarre enchantment and characterization proves boundless: Clementine's confidantes include a boy transfigured into a witty black sheep, a paper chicken that morphed from the family spell book, an amorphous snow figure who protects the area, and a huntress searching for a powerful unicorn. Anchoring the tale are the sensitive girl's conflicted feelings about inheriting the Dark Lord title, since she prefers flowers over weeds and spells that involve sunshine rather than darkness. In a wry, satisfying ending, Clementine hints at future enchantments ahead. Ages 10--up. Agent: Victoria Marini, Irene Goodman Agency. (Oct.)