School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 1-Cultures merge in this holiday story about a boy with an Indian mother, a Jewish father, and a mischievous little sister named Sadie. Instead of traditional potato pancakes, this family celebrates Hanukkah by making dosas, a fried Indian pancake of rice and beans. From buying ingredients at the Indian market, to grinding the dal and rice and frying the batter in coconut oil, the process feels both different and familiar, and creates an opportunity for the author to explore the mingling of traditions. Unfortunately, the first-person narrative is bogged down by a contrived plot focusing on Sadie's penchant for climbing on things and her brother's random discovery that he can make her get down by singing a modified version of "I had a little dreidel," which comes in handy when the family gets locked out of the house during their Hanukkah party. The colorful illustrations are festive and bright, including wonderful endpapers that highlight common ingredients used in Indian food, yet the visual appeal of this book does not compensate for the weakness of the text. Furthermore, references to the holiday itself at times seem offhanded: "Just like the Maccabees, my mom rubbed oil in a pan called a tawa, where we cook the dosas." VERDICT An additional selection for large holiday collections.-Teri Markson, Los -Angeles Public Library © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
Instead of frying latkes on Hanukkah, the family in Ehrenberg and Sarkar's sweet cross-cultural story makes dosas (a savory pancake served with condiments and side dishes) to honor Mom's heritage. "Making Indian food that my mom ate as kid for a Jewish holiday that my dad grew up with-that was a lucky combination," says the boy who candidly narrates. But he is also being sorely tested by his younger sister's mischievousness: if she won't behave will they ever get the dosas made-and get to eat them? Ehrenberg's storytelling leaves little to readers' imaginations, but there's something comforting about the steady step-by-step trajectory of the text and Sarkar's stylish cartooning. Readers will also appreciate how the narrator turns a customized version of "I Have a Little Dreidel" ("I have a little dosa...") into a sister-wrangling tool. Ages 4-7. Author's agent: Carrie Howland, Empire Literary. (Oct.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.