School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 2-Harking back to the fools of Chelm, the Knoodle family ponders the meaning of the rabbi's dictum, "It's hard to give the perfect gift, one that will be treasured forever." As Hanukkah approaches, each Knoodle draws a name out of a hat and attempts to give the perfect gift; unfortunately, the results are far from perfect. Everyone is thoroughly miserable, and it takes the rabbi to point out their error, that the perfect gift should be a treasure to the receiver, not to the giver. After a bit of reshuffling, they all end up with exactly what they wanted, making it the "best Hanukkah ever." This is less a Hanukkah story than a book about giving, making it suitable for all occasions when a gift is appropriate. Watercolor and pastel illustrations are colorful and exuberant, and the over-the-top expressiveness of the Knoodles' faces enhances the sense of fun.-Teri Markson, Los Angeles Public Library (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
The Knoodles (as in, they don't use theirs) have pondered the rabbi's comment about giving the perfect gift (one that will last forever) and, wanting to do right, set about choosing the best presents for each other. The revved-up expressions and high-wattage palette of the illustrations tip readers to expect exaggerated comedy, and sure enough, each Knoodle bestows what he or she would most like to receive. Why, wonders Bubby Sadie, does Little Yekl not treasure the pickle barrel that reminds her of Grandma Alte's in the old country (Such pickles she made!)? Goldin's (While the Candles Burn) best this is not, but adults who like slapshtick will enjoy sharing this with kids. Ages 5-8. (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved All rights reserved.
