School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 2-This pleasing blend of history and legend tells the story of a man who brought sparrows to America in the 1860s. John Bardsley loved these birds, though they were considered pests in England. He wound up in Philadelphia, where countless inchworms plagued the plants of the city. Bardsley journeyed back to his homeland and returned with a thousand sparrows that soon collected the worms for their hungry chicks. Gerstein's whimsical illustrations capture the spirited energy of this intriguing story. Crawling inchworms adorn the borders of several frames, and the sparrows finally reach outside the frame to eat them in the satisfying conclusion. Sparrow Jack, as he finally came to be called, is portrayed as a determined, ingenious, and endearing figure. The various expressions of the other people in the story reflect disgust, skepticism, surprise, and delight, depending on their reactions to Jack's ideas. The narrative tells just enough of the story to get readers firmly on the side of the inventive bird lover. The foreword, along with Jack's dream of talking sparrows, makes it clear that the fact-based story includes pleasing touches of imagination. Though the citizens of Philadelphia eventually complain about them, "those noisy little pests, the sparrows," are clearly heroes in this tale. An enjoyable and unusual bit of history.-Steven Engelfried, Beaverton City Library, OR (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
With the same gusto he brought to What Charlie Heard, Gerstein celebrates the accomplishments of another out-of-the-box thinker, John Bardsley. In 1868, the Englishman, newly transported to Philadelphia, imported 1,000 sparrows to the United States, averting the destruction of his new hometown's foliage by inchworms. This odd historical tidbit, in Gerstein's skilled hands, shapes up into a funny and engrossing tale. While a boy, Bardsley befriends a baby sparrow-one of a species viewed by the English as "greedy, noisy pests, but tasty snacks when roasted." The hero's fondness for the birds sparks his unusual idea about how to get Philadelphia's inchworm population into balance. Like composer Charlie Ives, Bardsley follows his vision despite naysayers. He transports the birds without the funding of the city council and shelters 1,000 sparrows in his home through the winter months. A living room scene, showing "Sparrow Jack" calmly reading a newspaper with birds perched on him from head to toe, embodies the whimsy of this story and the good nature of its hero. Humor and fancy augment every lightly hued, cross-hatched illustration. Gerstein decorates a number of scenes with a border of the ubiquitous inchworms, for example, and includes a dream sequence in which the birds debate the impending move ("Face facts. We're despised and hunted here"). Such playful touches make these humble little creatures soar. Ages 4-8. (May) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved